Utah co-op health insurer lost $19.9 million in first year

SALT LAKE CITY (AP) — A nonprofit Utah health insurer that received federal loans to get up and running lost nearly $20 million in its first year and is among co-ops around the country struggling with financial losses, according to a new audit.

The U.S. Health and Human Services inspector general’s office reported Thursday that all but one of the 23 co-ops around the country saw financial losses last year. A co-op in Maine was the exception.

Arches Mutual Insurance Co. in Utah is among those that lost money, reporting a $19.9 million loss for 2014.

The co-op insurers were created by President Barack Obama’s health care law and were awarded taxpayer-backed startup loans.

Arches received nearly $94 million.

Arches Chief Executive Officer Shaun Greene said Thursday that his company and most other insurers faced higher-than-expected costs when consumers signing up for the first year of coverage under the health care law were sicker and costlier than projected.

“It’s not simply just a co-op problem,” he said. “It’s an industry-wide problem.”

Greene said Arches expected to lose money in its first year, but the losses were about $10 million higher than expected.

To compensate for a more expensive group of patients, Arches is among many co-ops and traditional, for-profit insurers that plan to hike prices for health plans next year.

Greene also attributes the first-year losses to Utah’s decision not to insure more residents through the government-run Medicaid program and the steep costs of new prescription drugs. One of those is Sovaldi, a cure for hepatitis C infections that costs about $1,000 a pill.

Of the co-ops that lost money in 2014, about half of them saw far fewer people signing up than expected, bringing in less money through monthly premiums.

That wasn’t a problem in Utah, where Arches passed its enrollment goal by about 1,800 people.

They had 23,000 sign-ups last year, but Greene said Arches is on track to enroll about three times that by the end of 2015.

The co-op is hopeful that bump will help them break even this year.

Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!

Posted in Local